I guess that almost all internet users today know what email
is, and that it has a function called forward. Whenever there is a message
received with meaningful inspirations, practical and helpful techniques in
daily living, people tend to share it with their friends, hoping that their
friends will also gain the benefit as they do. As such, they forward the
message to their close friends, their family, or their colleagues. The
intention of forwarding is commendable, but sometimes it reflects logical
fallacy of the sender/ forwarder under certain circumstances. I shall present
and analyze the types of irrational forwarded messages, and really hope that
the senders really understand what they are forwarding and mean it when they do
so!
Case 1: Concerning the deletion of email account
Sample:
Good afternoon all msn / hotmail users,
Iam Tara and together with all the directors of MSN, we
apologized for the interruption. Please be informed that msn is closing down
due to the increasing numbers of inconsideration.
In our current report, it has clearly showed that there is
an overflowing percentage of population using one name to sign up for lots of
new and different accounts. This draws us to a shortage of new username accounts.
Reports have shown that we are left with only FIVE HUNDRED
AND SEVENTY EIGHT names. So this actually forced us to close down as many
wasted accounts as possible for our company sake.
To do so, our company has decided to use this idea.
If you would like to keep this existing account, please
kindly follow the instructions given below.
01: Copy this entire email.
02: Go back to inbox, and click on new
03: Right click paste
04: Sent this to all the names / emails address in your
contact.
(*To help you to ensure that you have followed to given
instructions, once you sent this email to all your names / emails address in
your contact , your msn will turn blue)
** Closing date: 30 JUNE 2008
If you would like to close your existing msn / hotmail
account, ignore the FOUR (04)steps given above.
It is surprising that people would believe in such a lie,
even the same message has been circulated among so many people, and even has
reached the same person for a few times. There are so many hints showing the
receiver that the fake message is not reliable. First, just look the title. It
is "Attention! Very very important!". From this we can already know
the personality of the sender, and the credibility of his/ her words. Second,
look at the constructed sentences. "If you would like to close your
existing msn/ hotmail account, ignore the 4 steps given above." Do you
think that person in charged will talk in this way? It is they who provide us
the service and thus make a profit. They don't speak in this way to their
customers. Third, look at the closing date, and the mentioned remaining account
numbers. Is the number still the same, after this message has been forwarded
after a few days? Forth, look at the status of the writer. Is writing this kind
of mail the job of director? Isn't it the work of administration staff?
Finally, if they really want to shut down, why don't they just send a mail to
us? Why do they want the message to be forwarded? Using this channel, there
might be people using their account, yet they don't receive this forwarded
message. If this is the case, will his account be closed? I have received many
forwarded messages of this kind, and I have NEVER take the instruction even
once, and, I am still enjoying the account.
Case 2: Concerning stirring up of emotional curiosity and
desperation
Sample 2A:
Because you opened this you will get kissed on Friday by the
love of your life..DO NOT BREAK THE CHAIN!!! Your crush will ask you out.
Tomorrow will be the best day of your life. However if you don't send this to
at least 10 people by midnight tonight you will have bad luck in your love
life. Every night, someone thinks about you before they go to sleep. At least
15 people in this world love you in some way. The only reason someone would ever
hate you is because they want to be just like you. There are at least 2 people
in this world that would die for you. You mean the world to someone. Someone
that you don't even know exists loves you. When you make the biggest mistake ever, something good comes from it.
When you think the world has turned its back on you, take a look again. Always
remember the compliments you received. Forget the rude remarks. So if you are a
loving friend, send this to your friends, including the person that sent it to you.
Tonight at midnight your true love will realize they like you. Something good
will happen to you at 1:00-4:00 pm tomorrow, it could be anywhere. Get ready
for the biggest shock in your life. Copy and paste and Send this to 15 people
in 15 minutes!
Sample 2B:
this really works~!!
> > > >Crush*************************
> > > >
> > > >FIND OUT WHO IT IS !
> > > >HERE'S WHAT U HAVE 2 DO BUT LISTEN VERY
CAREFULLY!!
> > > >SEND THIS LETTER 2 YOUR FRIENDS. AND IF U
DONT HAVE
> > >> ANY FRIENDS NO SWEAT
> > > >JUST GO 2 A CHATROOM PICK OUT SOME NAMES
AND BINGO!
> > > >BUT REMEMBER PASS IT ON!! AND IF U DON'T
PASS IT
> > >> YOU WILL PAY
> > > >WITH YOUR LIFE!!
> > > >U. HAVE ONE HOUR 2 SEND THIS SO HURRY.
> > > >AFTER U SEND THIS A SNAIL WILL CROSS THE
SCREEN AND
> > >> OUT OF
> > > >IT'S SHELL WILL POP OUT YOUR SECRET
CRUSH'S FIRST
> > >> AND LAST NAME
> > > >HIS/HER ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBER
> > > >IF U SEND THIS TO 0 PEOPLE-YOUR LUV LIFE
IS OVER!
> > > >5 PEOPLE- AND YOUR! CRUSH WILL SAY HE/SHE
LIKES U AS A FRIEND ONLY!
> > > >10 PEOPLE -AND YOUR CRUSH WILL SAY HE/SHE LIKES
U.
> > > >15 PEOPLE-AND YOUR CRUSH WILL ASK U OUT.
> > > >20 PEOPLE-AND YOUR CRUSH WILL ASK U OVER
HIS/HER HOUSE FOR DINNER.
> > > >25 PEOPLE-AND YOUR CRUSH WILL KISS U ON
THE LIPS!
> > > >30 PEOPLE-AND YOUR CRUSH WILL MARRY YOU
AND YOU'LL HAVE TWINS!!!
> > > >so do me a favor and pass it on!*****
> > > >tomorrow morning your crush will fall
madly in love
> > > >with you. You guys will
> > > >hook up, and your crush will ask you out.
Tomorrow
> > >> will be the best day of
> > > >your life. However, if you don't send
this to at
> > > >least 10 people bye @ least
> > > >10:00 tonight you will have bad luck in
you love
> > > >life for the rest of your
> > > >life This is not a stupid one or a fake.
Just copy
> > > >and paste. Start sending
I believe that everyone who forward this kind of message
knows how vain these messages are. Beginning with the writer of the messages:
Why does the writer hold such an attitude? Why does he/she curse people if they
don't forward the message? Second, does the writer know the future? Does the
writer have prophetic ability? If he/she really does, why not just keep silence
and predict his/her own future? Third, even I take the silly assumption that
the writer has this ability, the "prophecy" is too general,
meaningless, sounds childish and makes no sense. Why should I forward this
message to gain my good luck in the future? The writer is saying that we only
will have good love life if and only if we forward this message! How absurd it
is!
As far as the forwarder is concerned, even a slightly
thoughtful person knows that these kind of messages carries no truth at all.
The irony is this: If the forwarder knows that these messages are total
rubbish, why does he/she forward this again to others? Is it the intention of
the forwarder that all his/her friends know how lame he/she is? If the reader
believes these messages very much, let me tell you, declare to you, that it is
not true at all. The writer simply matches the common romantic situation to the
psychological desire or desperation of the common people and thus stirring up
the emotion of the reader, eg, "Your crush will say he/she likes u",
"Your crush will ask u out", "Your crush will marry you and have
a twins! (What a poor and uneducated overstatement!)" If these are the
moments that the reader anticipates deep within, then the probability that the
reader will be deceived is great.
Perhaps, the only answer to forwarding is the starred
sentence in sample 2B: "Do me a favor and pass it on". The writer, in
his/her immaturity and vanity of mind simply wants his/her messages to be
circulated among many, and therefore to enjoy seeing people sending this message
around.
Case 3: Concerning superstition and threats without
substantial basis
Sample 3A:
AFTER U READ THIS MSG,DUN THINK THD THIS IS FAKE COZ OTHER
PPL SAYS SO.NO!U HAVE NOW BEEN CONTROLLED AND CURSED.TONIGHT AT 3A.M WHEN U R
STILL SLEEPING LIKE A PIG,A PONTIANAK AND A THREE-EYED DEMON WILL COME AFTER
U.THE POTIANAK HAS LONG HAIR.FACE COVERED IN BLOOD AND WEARING A WHITE ROBE.THE
DEMON HAS THREE EYES,BLOODY BODY AND NO HAIR.THEY WILL USE A SCREW DRIVER,POKE
IT IN UR EYE BALL.THEN,THEY WILL USE A KNIFE,SEPERATE UR BODY IN TO HALF.NO
JOKE.I HAVE A FREN CALLED JUNIET.SHE TREAT THIS AS A RUBBISH AND JOKE.BUT WAD
HAPPEN?I,MYSELF FOUND HER DEAD IN HER BED.SHE APPEARED IN MY DREAMS AND TOLD ME
TO TELL U ALL TO BE CAREFUL.HER SON,CEDRIC WHITEHORSE,SEND THIS TO ONLY 2 PPL
AND HE FOUND HIMSELF,WITHOUT A ARM.IF U SEND THIS TO 0-10 PPL,DIE FOR SURE.IF U
SEN THIS TO 11-20 PPL,WUN DIE,JUST IN COMA.IF U SEND THIS TO 21 -100
PPL,CONGRATS!U WILL BE BLESSED 4EVA.BETTER DO IT IN 15 MINS,OR,DUN SLEEP
TONIGHT.TO KEEP A LOOKOUT......
Sample 3B:
10 Ways to describe if you are haunted...
Do you EVER get an eerie feeling if you are alone at home at
nightime, you just feel like you're being watched? Feel like someone is there
around that dark corner? That you might have seen toys or dolls moving by
themselves??
** Experts say there are some lifebeings that maybe arent
alive...thats still walking on earth. Nobody knows the truth. At least..nobody
thats still alive..**
The ten ways...
Point 1
If at midnight, the power's out.
Point 2
If your pet dog/cat is sleeping but they're eyes are wide
open.
Point 3
If your pet dog/cat is looking at something that you cant
see.
Point 4
If your pet dog/cat scratches at the air, or growls or hiss
at something you cant see.
Point 5
If something you see earlier on is at one place, later on it
is gone or moved someplace else.
Point 6
If theres a shadow of a figure against the wall, but there
is no one there.
Point 7
If you hear someone talking or whispering, but no one is
there.
Point 8
If suddenly outside the window, there is nothing but black.
Point 9
If you feel like something or someone is touching you.
Point 10
If the hair on your head and body is shooting up.
What other people say about this
~ Anelissa Kok, 16 ~
When I got this letter, I deleted it, thinking it was crap.
But, later on, strange things has happened to me. My mother had sex with our
dog, and my brother vanished without a single trace.
~ Shaza Reenaz, 32 ~
I deleted this letter as soon as I got it. Thinking that
kids were trying to fool me. But the next week, villagers found my 5 year old
daugther dead in a river, floating beside a woman with long white hair and a
white dress.
~ Kamilul Jalar, 14 ~
I didnt send this letter to other of my contacts. When at
the next day, my house was empty. Pure empty. Everything was gone. And what was
left was a package full of blood in my cupboard!
~ Mary Loo Mei, 13 ~
I deleted this letter as soon as I finished reading it. I
thought it was pure crap. Then, strange things had happened to me lately. My
boyfriend ran away from home, and he left a note to his parents that he is
going to kill himself. The next week, it was all over the papers that a boy
jumped of a high cliff.
If you dont want this to happen to you, might as well send
this letter. Its for your own good.
Send to 1-5 ppl, you will get bad luck for a year.
Send to 5-8 people, you will get bad luck for 6 months.
Send to 8-12 people, you will get bad luck for 10 hours.
Send to 12-20 people, good luck will be given to you for 3
years.
Example 3A is the worst forwarded message I have ever seen.
From the construction of the sentences as well as the spelling error, we can
deduce that the writer is not a proper person. The emotion of the message is
full of hatred, and the threatening was so bogus. Even after a considerably
long time thinking over it, I still can’t come out with a valid reason why was
this message written. The first time I read this message was at around
11pm-12am, and I was hoping so hard that whatever told will become true! It is
altogether out of mind and presumptuous.
As for sample 3B, I don’t feel like to comment on the 10
ways, but the testimony. They are obviously artificial, as there are many
unreasonable points. First, the testimonies made were so emotionless. If those
things really did happen to them, how could they testify in such a calm way?
Second, their ages are very suspicious. Does Kamilul Jamal of 14 own a house?
Does Mary Mei Loo of 13 already have a
boyfriend? Third, I am wondering: does the ghost know how to use computer? Does
it know how to check people email and thus it knows whether or not I forward
the mail? And, this ghost is also very peculiar: it only troubles those who
don’t forward this mail! And the ghost is so powerful! It can give luck to
people!
My purpose of presenting these examples is not to analyze
these mails one by one. My point is, does the reader even think before
forwarding them? Sorry to say, forwarding these messages carries no
significance at all; it simple reflects the ignorance of the forwarder.
Chatboard (2)